Accident victims in Illinois and Indiana have longstanding legal rights to pursue justice from those companies and individuals who are liable under the law for the accident itself and its aftermath. These are known as “personal injury cases” and they can be based upon a number of different legal theories. See, Flick, Cassandra, Narina Nunez, and Sean M. Laurent. “If negligence is intentionality’s cousin, recklessness is it’s sibling: Differentiating negligence and recklessness from accidents and intentional harm.” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 110 (2024): 104529.
- For instance, a steelworker hurt on the job may have a product liability claim against the manufacturer and other parties who breached duties of safety regarding a defective piece of machinery that caused their accident.
- Similarly, a factory accident caused by a piece of equipment or maybe a power tool that failed to warn of hazards may have a failure to warn claim against various third parties.
- Construction site accidents may involve legal claims based upon negligence or premises liability (among other things).
- Semi-truck crashes may find liability in state laws involving negligent supervision or training of the truck driver; negligent hiring of the carrier; and more.
For details, read: When Tools Are to Blame for Serious Work Accidents: Who’s Responsible? Product Liability; Warning Labels and Warning Signs: Liability After an Accident; and Expanded Semi-Truck Crash Liability: SCOTUS Rules Freight Brokers Are Liable for Negligent Choices in Transporting Goods.
When these accidents result in wrongful death of the victim, or cause life-altering bodily harm, the law provides the accident victim with specific monetary damages to cover both economic and non-economic damages. To learn more about these kinds of damages, and how they are distinct from worker’s compensation claim benefits, read Damages are Different: Worker’s Compensation vs. Third Party Personal Injury Claims.
1. Key Players in the Case: Experts For Both Liability and Damages
The injured victim has the responsibility to make formal demands upon the wrongdoers, after (1) determining who they are; and (2) what damages, as defined by law, have been sustained. Their case may be resolved in settlement or mediation, or it may be decided by a jury after trial.
In both Illinois and Indiana, the victim has the legal burden to prove their right to damages. The victim has to do so within a set period of time, too, or their claims will be barred by law no matter how meritorious.
See, Deadlines for Injury Victims to File Lawsuits: Statutes of Limitations.
It is an overwhelming challenge for most accident victims and their loved ones, who are simultaneously coping with medical care and treatment; lost earnings and wages; psychological and physical pain and suffering; etc. For this reason, many people who have been severely injured in a work accident; 18-wheeler crash; or motor vehicle collision will seek the help of experienced legal advocates who are practicing personal injury law in either Indiana or Illinois.
And while these lawyers will deal with the legal complexities of the matter, from researching; to gathering evidence and making sure it is admissible; to dealing with opposing counsel; and appearing on behalf of the victim in court, their skill alone will not be enough to meet that legal burden placed upon the injured person.
Experts will be needed on the victim’s team. Independent experts will be needed both to factually find out who caused the accident (there may be several wrongdoers) and to tally every bit of damage (economic and noneconomic) resulting from the accident.
These expert witnesses, both for liability and for damages, bridge the gap between all the technical details and factual realities in the accident and the legal substantiation needed to authenticate and admit their expert findings into evidence in the case.
2. Experts Will Explain Complex and Difficult Things in Everyday, Understandable Language
Finding fault in a complicated incident like a semi-truck crash or a fatal fall on a construction site can be very technical, and the experts working for the victim to find causation may return with findings that more than one party is to blame for what occurred.
Consider how a tractor-trailer’s digital data must be found, reviewed, and analyzed before the facts reveal themselves. Black box evidence requires the help of a trucking industry expert to help find answers, and then to explain them in everyday language that we can all understand.
Damage experts will also be adept at taking things like medical terminology and data and turning it into information that is readily understood about the financial consequences of the harm. For instance, a neurological expert will be able to discuss the long-term care needs that go along with a traumatic brain injury, helping everyone understand what a brain scan reveals about the victim’s permanent harm.
A good testifying expert will be approachable and able to communicate in ordinary language exactly what investigations were undertaken, and what their findings are, including preparing a written report that can supports their testimony in an easily understood manner.
3. Experts Are Objective Witnesses to Victim’s Personal Injury and Harm
Of course, the accident victim may have expertise and understanding of the nuances of their industry and how events transpired when they got hurt. This must be respected, but the defense will be ready to pounce on this testimony as being biased.
Expert witnesses have no personal stake in the matter, they are independent professionals employed to review things and form an opinion. They have an arms’ length approach to the case which brings with it credibility and respect that those personally involved in the situation cannot share.
This objectivity contribution cannot be underestimated. When a respected expert witness comes forward with a powerful report on liability or on damage totals, it may help the other side to come to a settlement as demanded by the victim’s legal advocates.
4. Experts May Include Those Testifying on Safety Regulations or Industrial Standards
In many situations here in Illinois and Indiana, accident scenarios are covered by industrial standards or federal safety regulations that have been violated in some way. While these may be a part of the legal team’s analysis of legal elements like negligence in a work accident, expert witnesses in the specific industry may also provide their take on things.
For instances, there may be safety regulation experts that provide testimony on how property owners or lessors, or various contractors, on a construction site were violating various regulations or industrial standards that resulted in an inherently dangerous work environment. Or, industrial hygienists may provide expert opinions on how exposure to hazardous materials or toxins, in violation of known standards or regulatory limits, contributed to the worker victim’s harm.
For more, see: What is Industrial Hygiene? Expert Protection of Workers on the Industrial Worksite.
5. Wrongful Death Damages: Expert Opinion on the Loss of a Human Life
Of particular importance in an accident where the victim failed to survive their bodily injuries, either at the time of the accident, or in the weeks or months ahead where they perished as a result of them, is the right under the laws of Illinois and Indiana to pursue “wrongful death claims” against those legally responsible for the accident.
Not only are liability experts vital here, but damage experts are extremely important in proving up the damage claims brought by the victim’s estate and their survivors. For instance:
Forensic experts will be needed to calculate in a way that withstands defense challenge the total loss of earning capacity of the deceased over their expected remaining work life. Forensic pathologists will explain conscious pain or mental horror suffered by the victim before their death in quantifiable terms. Mental health experts may provide opinions on things suffered by the grieving loved ones, such as the depression of the surviving spouse or the trauma suffered by the surviving children, as loss of consortium, etc.
For more, read: Wrongful Death Claims in Illinois and Indiana: Different Laws Providing Justice after a Fatal Injury.
Experts Are Important to Personal Injury Claims for Justice
Each accident victim’s situation is unique and every matter must be given its individual consideration and respect. Working together with their legal advocates, the specific needs in expert analysis and testimony will be considered and various independent professionals considered before being hired to assist.
Experts must be considered for the significant contributions they bring to the victim’s claims for justice after they have been harmed due to the acts (or failures to act) of others. Of note, the defense teams will also have their own set of experts to challenge every bit of the accident victim’s case.
In both the confirmation of liability of the wrongdoers, and the substantiation of all the damages resulting from their bad acts, the expert witnesses are often unsung heroes in the plaintiff’s case.
For more, read:
- Accident Victim’s Expert Opinion Testimony: Defense Tactics to Discredit or Exclude Plaintiff’s Experts
- Indiana Truck Crash Victims and Representation by Board-Certified Attorneys in Truck Accident Law
- Common Defense Arguments Against Damage Claims Used to Try and Minimize Payout
- The Steel Industry is Dangerous: How Can Personal Injury Attorneys Help Steel Workers Hurt on the Job?
- Are There Civil Claims for Damages Against Third-Parties for Your Work Accident?
Severe or deadly accidents in Indiana and Illinois may form the basis of legal claims for damages that will need expert testimony to withstand the denials of responsibility and culpability made by those who caused the harm. Please be careful out there!